Media Law: Recent Work
By its very nature, the majority of Carter-Ruck’s pre-publication and privacy-related work is confidential and must remain so. However, a selection of recent media and defamation work highlights which are in the public domain is set out below.
Simon Cowell secures apology from Mail on Sunday
The publishers of the Mail on Sunday have published an apology to Simon Cowell.
Tamara Ecclestone loses “custody battle” over Lamborghini
Ecclestone v Elite Motors  EWHC 29 (QB)
The High Court has now given judgment in the dispute which followed what was widely reported as the “custody battle” between Tamara Ecclestone and her former boyfriend Omar Khyami over ownership of a Lamborghini Aventador which he claimed (and she denied) had been given to him as a birthday present.
In his judgment Dingemans J found that the car had indeed been a gift to Mr Khyami and that the interim injunction which Ms Ecclestone had obtained had been given on the basis of false evidence. As the car had in fact belonged to Mr Khyami at the relevant time, he had been entitled to sell the car to Elite Motors which had in turn been entitled to sell it on. Ms Ecclestone was accordingly liable to the remaining parties in the case and was ordered to deliver up the car and pay damages.
Former RAF Dean secures libel win against Associated Newspapers
Professor Joel Hayward, the former Dean of RAF College Cranwell and a prominent and respected academic in the fields of international politics and modern conflict, has secured substantial damages, an apology and costs from Associated Newspapers in respect of false allegations made against him in articles published in the Mail on Sunday and Daily Mail and on the MailOnline website in August 2011. Associated Newspapers apologised for its false allegations to the effect that the beliefs of Professor Hayward, who is a Muslim, had prevented him from fulfilling his duty of impartiality and fairness as a teacher in the RAF and had caused him to show undue favouritism to Islamic students and to spend too much time on Islamic activities as opposed to his professional and academic obligations.
This settlement follows the publication of an apology by the Daily Star last year concerning similar false allegations it had made about Professor Hayward.
Carter-Ruck acted for Professor Hayward on a ‘no win, no fee’ basis and with the benefit of ATE insurance cover provided by Temple Legal Protection.
Prime Minister Mbabazi of Uganda
Associated Newspapers has apologised in Court to Prime Minister Mbabazi for articles headed “£10m foreign aid went to cronies of Ugandan PM”, and “Britain and Ireland suspend aid to Uganda after £10m of funding ends up in Prime Minister’s account”. In a Statement in Open Court, Associated Newspapers confirmed the publishers had undertaken not to repeat the allegations and agreed to pay Prime Minister Mbabazi a substantial sum in damages, together with his legal costs.
Tristram Cokes – Libel success against Yachting World Magazine
Tristram Cokes, a well-known surfer and businessman, has secured a full apology as well as substantial libel damages over false allegations which appeared in Yachting World magazine.
The Mail apologises and pays £110,000 in libel damages over chemical weapons libel
The publisher of the Daily Mail has apologised for an article on its website which falsely linked Britam Defence Ltd (a leading UK-based risk management and training consultancy), and two of its senior Directors (David Goulding and Philip Doughty) with an alleged plot to carry out a chemical weapons atrocity in Syria.
British charity receives apology and libel damages from Jewish Chronicle
The CEO and Trustees of British charity Human Appeal International have received an apology and substantial damages from the Jewish Chronicle following publication of untrue allegations concerning the charity’s activities and status.
Isabel Martorell is quoted in the Independent newspaper, concerning privacy law issues arising out of controversial facebook pages which encouraged students anonymously to rate the performance of their sexual partners.
Libel Success for Hardeep Singh
Carter-Ruck has successfully represented journalist Hardeep Singh in his libel claim against actor Rizwan Ahmed. The claim concerned false allegations about Mr Singh that were published on Twitter by Mr Ahmed.
Mr Ahmed has provided Mr Singh with a formal apology and has agreed to pay him substantial damages for libel and his legal costs.
Click here for a further report on the matter.
Tunisian party leader secures libel success against BBC
Rached Ghannouchi, leader of the Tunisian political party Ennahda, has received an apology and substantial damages from the BBC following publication of untrue allegations on its website.
Amir Khan successfully defends libel claim
Carter-Ruck has successfully represented British boxer Amir Khan, a former two-time world champion, against a substantial libel claim brought by a fellow boxer.
Kate and Gerry McCann
Carter-Ruck brought a successful application for contempt of Court against an individual who had repeatedly published false and highly defamatory allegations about the couple, in breach of formal undertakings which he had given to the Court in 2009. Recognising the seriousness and persistency of the individual’s conduct, the Court imposed a three-month suspended prison sentence. The individual has subsequently agreed to withdraw an appeal of the committal order, to abide by his undertakings in future and to pay costs to the Claimants.
Carter-Ruck advised an LSE student who participated in a visit to North Korea, which found itself at the centre of a much-publicised row between the LSE and the BBC. The trip had been covertly organised by the BBC as a means of allowing Panorama journalists surreptitiously to enter and film the country. However, the BBC had not informed the students of the true purpose of the trip, or the danger which they faced if the Panorama journalists (who were all posing as students) were caught filming by the North Korean authorities. The BBC’s conduct attracted widespread criticism including from Ben Bradshaw MP, the LSE and various other academic bodies including the Royal Society and the British Academy.
The Guardian - BBC denies endangering students with undercover visit to North Korea
Daily Mail - Students put at risk for an ego-boosting stunt
The Telegraph - Risking students' lives in North Korea was worth it, says BBC
BBC World News
Carter-Ruck Partner Isabel Martorell was interviewed by Zeinab Badawi on BBC World News Today, discussing the privacy proceedings brought in France following the taking of paparazzi photographs of the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge while on holiday there last year.
Fresh Consulting and Support Limited – Libel success against London Borough of Hillingdon
Fresh Consulting and Support Limited, a company which provides computer services and products to schools and businesses, has succeeded in its libel complaint against the London Borough of Hillingdon. The claim concerned false allegations which were made in a letter sent out to schools by the Council. The Council has paid Fresh Consulting substantial damages for libel and will also pay its legal costs.
CJC Working Group report published
The Working Group commissioned by the Civil Justice Council (of which Alasdair Pepper was a member) has now published its final report. The Working Group had been tasked with identifying the need, and possible mechanisms, for providing costs protection to parties to publication and privacy proceedings, in order to help preserve access to justice in light of the reforms to the CFA regime and the end of recoverable After The Event premiums.
The Court of Appeal has refused Tanzanian businessman Reginald Mengi permission to appeal Mr Justice Bean’s dismissal of his libel claim against Sarah Hermitage. Lord Justice Maurice Kay concluded that Mr Justice Bean had “disbelieved and rejected” the evidence adduced by Mr Mengi. The Judge found that Mr Mengi had no real prospect of success in pursuing an appeal.
Carter-Ruck is pleased to announce that it has been appointed to BT’s network of external advisers.
Sir Benjamin Slade - libel success against local Council
Sir Benjamin Slade has received a full apology over false allegations which were published on the website of Sedgemoor District Council concerning an application to hold a festival on Sir Benjamin’s land at Maunsel House in Somerset, which is a venue for weddings and festivals. Both the author of the comments and the Council have apologised to Sir Benjamin for their role in publishing the remarks and have paid him damages and his legal costs.
British claimant in libel success against French newspaper
Nicola Takieddine has received an apology and a sum in damages from the French language daily newspaper, Libération. Ms Takieddine, a British citizen living in London, brought proceedings in relation to allegations published in October and November 2011 by Libération, which has a readership in England and Wales. The newspaper provided an undertaking not to repeat the allegations, and has agreed to join in the reading of a Statement in open Court.
Hedge fund founder secures privacy injunction and £50,000 in damages
Elena Ambrosiadou, founder and CEO of the IKOS hedge fund, has succeeded in her privacy claim against her estranged husband Martin Coward. Mr Coward agreed to submit to a permanent injunction, and to pay £50,000 in damages, after he leaked a document to the press containing private information about Ms Ambrosiadou and her son, which he had served in family proceedings which were ongoing between the parties in Greece.
Partner Andrew Stephenson comments on access to justice in libel cases
John Yates in libel victory against Met Police Commissioner
Former Assistant Metropolitan Police Commissioner John Yates has succeeded in his libel complaint against Commissioner Bernard Hogan-Howe. In April this year, the Commissioner circulated a memorandum to the Home Secretary, Foreign Office and senior and middle-ranking police officers which contained false and defamatory allegations about Mr Yates. The Commissioner has now issued a correction and agreed to make a donation to Mr Yates' chosen charity, the Police Widows & Orphans Fund, and pay Mr Yates' legal costs.
News of the World phone hacking success
Carter-Ruck has successfully settled claims on behalf of victims of News of the World phone hacking, with each client obtaining a substantial sum in damages. The victims were represented by Ruth Collard, Luke Staiano and Zoe Brocket.